The latest round of subway cuts, announced yesterday, are cutting cleaning crews and administrative positions. This is in addition to other plans announced earlier in the year that would cut cards for students, get rid of the W line, shorten other lines, and shorten bus routes. And I’m not sure about other folks, but it seems like the subways, at least in my part of Brooklyn, are getting more crowded. (This Times interactive piece shows that in other areas, it may not be the case.)

Courtesy ConcurringOpinions.com
Not that I’m an MTA decision maker or anything, but I often think while I’m waiting for the 2/3 of what could be done to help the MTA. What do I use and what don’t I use? Could the seats be changed to fit more people in? What times do I never use the train? What times are they too slow? How can the subways get better and save money?
A couple of thoughts I had:
Do we really need station agents? I have never, since I moved to New York, talked to one of these agents. On off hours, I frequently find my local station agent asleep. What function do they serve? They can combine cards for people who have cards with half of a fare on them – could the automatic machines do that instead? They give information – could a portal serve the same function (and stay awake at all hours)?
Could we have double decker cars? This one I’m not so sure about. The roof seems like it might too low, but they could dig the tracks a little deeper, potentially, to accommodate a taller car like those of NJ Transit. I’m not sure how much cars like these would cost though. Perhaps they could buy these for the 2nd Avenue subway line, since they will probably need to buy new cars anyway. If the cars accommodate more people, perhaps they could save a driver or two by running just a little less frequently.
Cell phone service. Could they offer a cell phone company the exclusive rights to provide service underground, like Verizon has in DC? This would be a win-win because (some) riders would have the ability to use their phones on their commutes and the MTA could make money by allowing the carrier to provide the service at a fee.
Fines. This may be my favorite. Fine people on the subway who play their music too loud or litter. It may be difficult to enforce if riders don’t have IDs. Maybe they ask for a rider’s Metro card and remove the money from their fare card.
Charges. Charge people for bringing extra-bulky items like bicycles and strollers (Park Slopers, don’t hate me!). The bulky items take up more room in the cars, why shouldn’t they cost more to carry?
Tunnel lights. What in the world is the purpose of lights in an empty tunnel, for example on the track between Manhattan and Brooklyn on the 2/3? There are already lights on the trains for passengers and I would imagine it’s rare for someone to walk down a tunnel alone. Most MTA workers carry flashlights when they’re going down a tunnel, anyway. If they are going to have them, I would say make them motion sensitive and turn them off shortly after the motion stops.
MTA uniforms. Let MTA employees wear jeans and a t-shirt. Who really cares what they wear? Why should we pay for uniforms that serve little purpose.
Ok, maybe I’m being too harsh, but I think there are creative ways to deal with any budget crisis, be it your family’s food budget or a major city’s subway system budget.
Feel free to goad me on this one! What do you use? What is a waste?